New York Pizza FI
opens at 11:00 today
Pizza place Restaurant
Family owned & operated New York style pizzeria located in Fleming Island, Florida. Offering dine-in, take-out and delivery. Update description
Reviews
Updates (5)
Review New York Pizza FI
Loading comments-box...
Carin Rutherford C. 2015-07-17Ever since I first had authentic New York Pizza in New York (twenty-three years ago) I am very, very picky about my pizza, if I order a pizza, it has...
Andrew J. 2018-08-14Great NY style pizza like it should. Thin, but it still stays straight. A little bit of grease covered by the awesome cheese. Def made right. If you...
Josh W. 2018-07-13Terrible pizza -Horrible service! I would rather eat hot dog shit off of the sidewalk! Run by filthy, unsanitary, rude teenagers and an incompetent...
Katie L. 2018-05-03Service is terrible. I would put 0 but it is not an option.
Linda R. 2018-02-07Pizza was very good. Had not had a good pizza since leaving NJ/NY in the late 70's
Sandra N Cliff B. 2017-10-15Best pizza around people and service too.
Richard C. 2017-10-01My daughters and I loved the food! The service was exceptional!
Laura M. 2017-05-03Best pizza in Fleming Island. Love the atmosphere and the great customer service.
Lenny M. 2017-04-30Finally found that Pizza
Peter P. 2017-03-05Please please tell me why when a customer calls do you ask cash or credit card? I said cash and the delivery driver showed up with exactly NO CHANGE...
Brad P. 2017-03-05Love the 24" delicious and so fun! Even deliver right to our house.
Robert L. 2017-02-05Best in town, we've been steady customers for years.
Karen B. 2017-02-03REALLY GREAT tasting pizza and VERY NICE SERVICE DEFFINATELY GOING BACK
Tim R T. 2017-01-22Best pizza in the area, when you grew up having puzza in Nj.
Norma Hicks A. 2016-10-08This establishment just earned a new customer tonight! They opened up after the storm was mostly gone. The family who own the business worked all the...
Ashlee A. 2016-10-07Friendly staff, great pizza!! The garlic knots are delicious!
Laurie White L. 2016-09-07They have the BEST antipasto salad on the island!!! Hands down
Laura LJ M. 2016-09-06We ordered the pizza rolls. I think we are for two full days on them. We ordered the small too. This is our new favorite place.
Carol B. 2016-08-20This is our go-to pizza place. Family owned and pizza is amazing!
Carlos R. 2016-07-09Sorry i feel like i can not properly review this awesome place because it ONLY allows me to give them 5 stars..... The Pizza "IS" New York pizza. By...
Updates from New York Pizza FI
New York Pizza F. 2015-05-23
What are your favorite toppings to put on your pizza?
What are your favorite toppings to put on your pizza?
New York Pizza F. 2015-05-22
#CustomerAppreciationDay
#CustomerAppreciationDay
New York Pizza F. 2015-05-22
#CustomerAppreciationDay
#CustomerAppreciationDay
New York Pizza F. 2015-05-22
Stop in for a quick appetizer to brighten up your day! :)
Stop in for a quick appetizer to brighten up your day! :)
New York Pizza F. 2015-05-21
Come try our Antipasto Salad for lunch today! A colorful and delicious salad made with a variety of cold meats, cheeses, olives, roasted peppers, and vegetables! #NewYorkPizza #Salad #Food #FlemingIsland
Come try our Antipasto Salad for lunch today! A colorful and delicious salad made with a variety of cold meats, cheeses, olives, roasted peppers, and vegetables! #NewYorkPizza #Salad #Food #FlemingIsland
Popularity of New York Pizza FI
Social Media Popularity Score: This value is based on the number of visitors, checkins, and likes on Facebook in the last few months.
Most activity in May:
New York Pizza FI has a total of 688 visitors (checkins) and 1099 likes.
20 reviews of New York Pizza FI.
Average grade
4.4
av 5.
Brew-Bakers Cafe & Co.
Mr. Chubbys Fleming Island